Re: Bollocks to Brexit
Posted: Tue Apr 02, 2019 1:55 pm
It won't, and I haven't argued otherwise. But you must surely accept that there are significant divisions in other countries that are not planning to leave the EU.LowlifeDes wrote: ↑5 years agoThey might, if we were to take notice of them and then seek to address them. As it stands though, those issues are being cynically harnessed for a purpose and, once that purpose is served, they will be ignored again. How would this help anything?
There are, but it would appear that some of those rifts and divisions are being caused by the same propaganda and possibly even funded, advised and influenced by the same individuals and states. It is to our shame that we have allowed ourselves to become enthralled and even controlled by them.
It's not, on the whole, the Remainers who are refusing to give way on continued membership of the CU and SM but the Brexiteers...ransos wrote: ↑5 years agoIt depends on how you look at it. Literally, you are correct, but leaving with membership of the CU and SM would not make any noticeable difference to the vast majority of the population.
The morning after the referendum, I took the view that we needed to respect the result, whilst making the best of a bad situation. That view hasn't changed.
I did. What of it?
You are arguing against a view I do not hold. I have never argued that a compromise, such as CU + SM membership, gives us every benefit of the EU. I am arguing that it's a pragmatic solution that would most likely not be noticeable on a day-to-day basis, to most people. I am also arguing that the forces precipitating Brexit are also prevalent in large swathes of the EU - Five Star, Front Nationale, AfD - and require addressing irrespective of continued membership or not.LowlifeDes wrote: ↑5 years agoYou are missing all the other things that our membership gives us, which those people behind Brexit would gladly take away once they can.
And that, in a nutshell, is why we're at an impasse.LowlifeDes wrote: ↑5 years agoMy position on this is entrenched, and I am not in the slightest bit ashamed of it. There are moments in history for people to be on one side or another, and I think that this is one of them.
Not really. We are not at an impasse because of my intransigence in not wishing to accept something which will negatively effect just about everybody in the UK, including of course less opportunities for children than their parents enjoyed, which to me is utterly unacceptable. We are at an impasse because we had a binary referendum offering an undefined prize, carried out in an illegal and morally bankrupt manner.
I can't agree with that, or with the idea that your pragmatic solution will mean most people will not notice any difference. I find it extraordinary that you would believe this after all the evidence that has been offered to the contrary. I would begin to outline it to you all over again, but I have a feeling that would not go down well. Sonic has it right on the nail.
Gosh, how perceptive of you to understand that patronizing me might not go down well.Rutabaga wrote: ↑5 years agoI can't agree with that, or with the idea that your pragmatic solution will mean most people will not notice any difference. I find it extraordinary that you would believe this after all the evidence that has been offered to the contrary. I would begin to outline it to you all over again, but I have a feeling that would not go down well. Sonic has it right on the nail.
What makes you think I wish to accept it? Nevertheless, we are where we are, for reasons that go rather deeper than the way in which the referendum was conducted. I haven't gone back through all of this thread, but I don't recall any serious attempt to describe what a better EU looks like, nor why people might be persuaded to support it.Sonic Budgie wrote: ↑5 years agoNot really. We are not at an impasse because of my intransigence in not wishing to accept something which will negatively effect just about everybody in the UK, including of course less opportunities for children than their parents enjoyed, which to me is utterly unacceptable. We are at an impasse because we had a binary referendum offering an undefined prize, carried out in an illegal and morally bankrupt manner.